For years, the MBA has been sold as a career accelerator. Stuck in middle management? Get an MBA. Want to switch industries? Get an MBA. Want to be taken seriously as a future executive? Get an MBA.
That story is getting harder to defend.
A recent Wall Street Journal article by Ray A. Smith highlighted the problem through the story of Kevin Vado. Kevin Vado entered the University of Florida’s full-time, two-year MBA program in 2024 after working in banking at Morgan Stanley and Wells Fargo. He hoped the degree would help him pivot into brand management. After graduating, he had applied to roughly 200 positions and networked with more than 80 alumni at large companies. Yet he still told the Journal that it had been tough even getting interviews.
That should stop people in their tracks.
This is not a story about someone who failed to try. Two hundred applications is not casual effort. Eighty alumni conversations is not passivity. Vado did what the MBA machine tells students to do: enroll in a reputable program, build the network, use the alumni base, and go after the next step.
Still, the interviews were hard to get.
And this was not some obscure, third-tier program. The University of Florida’s Warrington College of Business describes itself as Florida’s No. 1 business school and lists its full-time MBA as No. 17 among public programs in the 2026 U.S. News rankings. (UF Warrington College of Business) UF also promotes the full-time MBA as having strong ROI, including a 94% full-time job-offer rate by three months post-graduation and a No. 4 ROI ranking based on salary and debt for $100K-plus earners. (UF Warrington College of Business)
That is exactly why the example matters.
If someone can attend a well-regarded, highly marketed, top-public MBA program, spend two full-time years pursuing the credential, put in real effort on applications and networking, and still struggle to get interviews, then the problem is not simply the student. The problem is the premise.
The premise is that the credential itself changes the market’s perception of you.
For most people, it does not.
UF’s published graduate tuition and fees list the full-time two-year MBA at $25,473 for Florida residents and $63,738 for out-of-state students, before considering the opportunity cost of leaving the workforce or slowing down career progression for two years. (UF Warrington College of Business) That means the real cost is not just tuition. It is the money spent, the income not earned, the professional momentum paused, and the two years that could have been spent building a track record inside an actual business.
That is the part MBA marketing rarely wants to confront.
The market does not hire degrees. It hires demonstrated capability.
In a recent meeting with a regional bank CEO, we discussed this exact article. His reaction matched what I hear from leaders across industries: companies are not starving for more academic credentials. They are starving for people who can do the work, lead teams, solve hard problems, communicate clearly, and create measurable value.
Executives want leaders. They want doers. They want people who have been close to the pressure, the customer, the numbers, the execution, and the consequences.
They do not want someone whose main proof of readiness is that they stepped away from the real world for two years to study case discussions about it.
That does not mean every MBA is worthless. There are exceptions. Some specialized programs make sense. Some technical, finance, consulting, healthcare, defense, or internal corporate leadership paths may explicitly reward or require the credential. Some large organizations have rotational programs where an MBA is part of the structure. And for someone already on a clear executive track inside a company, an MBA may help check a box.
But for the average professional who thinks an MBA will magically unlock a better career, the math is getting brutal.
The Wall Street Journal article notes that unemployment for workers under 35 with master’s degrees has rarely been higher in the past 20 years, according to Burning Glass Institute data. The article also quotes Burning Glass chief economist Gad Levanon’s explanation: there are more degrees chasing fewer of the roles those degrees were supposed to unlock.
That is the core issue. The MBA used to be a stronger signal because fewer people had one. Once the market is flooded with graduate business degrees, the signal weakens. At that point, employers return to the question they should have been asking all along: what have you actually done?
Drexel University’s 2026 College Hiring Outlook points in the same direction. The report says hiring activity has softened across degree levels, and that hiring plans for MBAs and other advanced professional degree holders are more limited. It also says employers are prioritizing role readiness, applied skills, and organizational fit over volume hiring.
That phrase — role readiness — is the entire argument.
Role readiness is not built primarily in a classroom. It is built by owning projects, managing tradeoffs, working under constraints, learning how departments actually function, dealing with customers, presenting to executives, making mistakes, and being accountable for results.
For most ambitious professionals, the better move is not to ask, “Should I get an MBA?”
The better move is to ask your boss:
“What can I take off your plate that matters?”
“What project would expose me to the economics of this business?”
“Where can I get closer to customers, revenue, operations, or long-term growth?”
“What do I need to learn to become more valuable here?”
“How can I be involved in strategic planning, business development, process improvement, or a cross-functional initiative?”
Those questions cost nothing. They do not require stepping out of the workforce. They do not bury someone in debt. And they often create exactly the kind of experience employers actually care about.
The irony is that many people pursue an MBA to prove they are leadership material, while the most direct way to become leadership material is to lead something.
Run the project. Fix the broken process. Build the relationship. Own the metric. Help develop the new product. Learn the financials. Sit with the sales team. Spend time with operations. Ask why margins are moving. Understand how hiring decisions get made. Volunteer for the messy initiative nobody wants because it is politically complicated or operationally difficult.
That is where business education actually happens.
An MBA can teach frameworks. It can introduce vocabulary. It can create a network. It can help someone think in a more structured way about strategy, finance, marketing, and operations. Those are not meaningless benefits.
But they are not worth $60,000-plus and two years of opportunity cost if the degree does not materially change your career trajectory.
And increasingly, for many people, it does not.
The hard truth is that an MBA is often a very expensive form of permission-seeking. People use it to delay the uncomfortable work of asking for more responsibility, taking a risk, building credibility, or proving themselves in the actual market. It feels productive. It feels prestigious. It feels like forward motion.
But forward motion is not the same as progress.
Progress is when the market values you more because you can do something valuable.
That is why Vado’s story is so important. Again, this is not a criticism of him. By the facts presented, he appears to have worked hard, networked aggressively, and pursued a reasonable goal. The criticism is of a system that tells ambitious people the credential itself is the bridge.
For too many, it is not a bridge. It is a toll road.
Before someone spends two years and tens of thousands of dollars on an MBA, they should ask a colder question: what job, promotion, client base, or internal path does this degree specifically unlock that I cannot reach through experience, execution, and targeted skill-building?
If the answer is vague, inspirational, or based on prestige, keep your money.
Go build the resume the market actually wants.
Sources
- Ray A. Smith, The Wall Street Journal — A Master’s Degree Isn’t the Job Guarantee It Used to Be
- Rankings – UF Warrington College of Business
- Full-Time MBA Degree Program- UF Warrington College of Business
- Graduate Costs, Scholarships & Financial Aid | UF Warrington
share